Herzog, lover of life, big bets, and attention has plenty of screen-time, and can’t help but snatch the storyline and make it his own. This is the same man who, to settle a bet involving good friend Errol Morris, ate his own shoe. (Blank turned that into a film—“Werner Herzog Eats His Shoe”—which is included on the Criterion release of “Burden.”) What a ham! But, what could have turned into a hagiographic puff piece is, in Blank’s hands, a complex and enriching work of journalistic non-fiction. The film tracks “Fitzcarraldo” from pre-production (starting in 1979) to its completion, employing a combination of visual strategies to tell this story, which improbably drifts from horror show to comedy and back again. Striving for authenticity, Herzog trades one Peruvian village for another, recycling through two co-stars (Jason Robards, Mick Jagger) and countless injuries, death threats, and setbacks to chase his dream.
Blank: A Generous, Open-Minded Auteur
In Herzog’s scenes, Blank’s camera doesn’t exactly fixate on the director. Instead, it wanders to incorporate the natural world which is winning every battle waged against it. When Narrator Candace Laughlin talks about the working conditions (dangerous-to-perilous) and wages (double the average pay rate, yet a fraction of the creative team’s) of the local tribespeople, she delivers the news without editorializing. The viewer can determine if Herzog and his crew are fair laborers or exploitative. My opinion: neither extreme captures the truth; but ultimately, Blank is a generous, open-minded auteur, featuring as much camaraderie (Herzog playing soccer with the locals) as chaos (knife-toting women fighting over a philandering husband). Since Blank was a close friend of Herzog, there’s the question of objectivity, but the full portrayal of danger (an arrow nearly kills two people) leaves little room for a cliche commentary on the joy of creating.
When I first saw “Burden of Dreams” five years ago, I was smack in the middle of a Herzog honeymoon phase, discovering his entire oeuvre for the first time. I still count several of his films among my favorites (“Stroszek” in particular) but now at a remove from that period, “Burden” is so much different than I remember. Herzog surely has the most memorable moments, but it’s the zealous professionalism of Blank and his team which stands out. Like an investigative reporter in the bunker, Blank doesn’t profess to show the best or worse of human nature. He presents these complicated humans out in nature, and allows all accomplices to tell their own story. What strikes me about Herzog now isn’t his artistic vision or a perceived reckless imperialist impulse, but his conflicted morality. The jungle is “obscene,” far from “erotical,” and yet, he loves it “against my better judgment.”
A New 4K Screening at Film Forum
Blank’s reporting skills serve—rather than contradict—his essayistic approach, evoking Joan Didion. At a slight remove, both Blank and Didion could embrace and analyze a sub-culture that fascinated them, without compromising the integrity of an objective observer. Similar to the wonderful and weird “Garlic Is as Good” (some sly self-promotion: Herzog and crew wearing shirts advertising that film in “Burden”), Blank is not shy about his advocacy for his subjects. And a cyclical theme in “Burden” is watching what happens when cast and crew aren’t filming, as if Blank is reminding us that these lives can’t be reduced to how they perform for a camera. Once filming completes, Blank, Herzog, et al can go home, but for those who are already home, life—and, according to the closing credits, the fight to obtain legal title to their land—resumes.
Browse through any streaming service, and it appears there’s a documentary boom. But the subject matter—true crime and murder—is in short supply, implying a surfeit of quantity, not quality. Blank’s film bares all about a messy, catastrophic production process, managing to be endlessly suspenseful and entertaining. Despite having already seen “Fitzcarraldo” and “Burden,” I watched in nervous anticipation, understanding that carrying a steamship over a hill is an absurd endeavor, bound to have an incalculable human—and calculable financial—cost. Instead of ending with that pivotal moment, Blank films the native Peruvians—multi-hyphenates in their own right—behind the camera, taking pictures and making collages featuring Blank, Herzog, and others. It takes a village to chase after a foolish dream, and Blank posits that no one person is responsible for the final long shot realized; it’s a group effort to transfer a gigantic burden to the big screen.
A new 4K restoration of “Burden of Dreams,” an Argot Pictures release, will screen at Film Forum from July 19th-July 25th, before a limited national rollout. Film Forum will also offer select screenings of “Fitzcarraldo” during the “Burden of Dreams” run.
