Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    The Movie Buff
    Subscribe
    • Home
    • About
      • Critics
      • Press & Testimonials
      • Friends of the Buff
      • Terms of Use
      • Thank You!
    • Film Reviews & Coverage
      • Movie Reviews
      • TV/Streaming Reviews
      • Film Festival Coverage
      • Interviews
    • Podcasts
    • Indie Film
      • Reviews & Articles
    • Advertise
    • Contact
      • Write for us
    The Movie Buff
    Animation

    Tribeca Festival 2023 Review: Thoughtful Storytelling and Craftsmanship Make ‘Starling’ a Delicate Short About Grief and Loss

    Paul Emmanuel Enicola By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 13, 2023No Comments3 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email Copy Link
    A scene from the short film Starling
    The titular little star, in a scene from the short film "Starling." (Photo: Tribeca Festival 2023).
    Share
    Facebook Twitter Email Copy Link

    A couple prepare a small celebration in their house one night, partaking in an occasion opposite an empty chair across the table. Meanwhile, the night skies temporarily shine bright as a protostar (or in this case, a starling) fumbles its landing on the ground.

    Despite clocking in at just under 10 minutes, “Starling” packs an emotionally poignant punch. Without writing a single line of dialogue, director Mitra Shahidi delicately captures the depths of grief, offering a profound exploration of human emotions that makes it even more compelling.

    A scene from Mitra Shahidi's animated short film
    Blending in: A scene from “Starling.” (Photo: Tribeca Festival 2023).

    A Story Inspired by the Filmmaker’s Memories of Childhood and Personal Loss

    As an international collaboration among a community of diverse artists and animators across the globe, “Starling” brings to life filmmaker Shahidi’s childhood during the ‘90s Istanbul. A bustling night market alongside, men playing Tavla, coffee sessions at night, the feral cats — the animated short depicts them all in full 2D glory. 

    These, however, provide the perfect juxtaposition to the somber mood in one particular household. Fortunately, an adorable pudgy starling still fumbles its way to where it needs to go, and which might help lighten the mood. In the end, we get to understand why the little star landed in the first place. And it’s a reveal that’s almost guaranteed to put a lump in the audience’s throat. 

    Also inspired by the loss of Shahidi’s childhood friend in 2018, “Starling” movingly captures the essence and emotion of that loss. It was produced through Pixar’s co-op program which allows employees to leverage equipment available at the studio to further their own creative pursuits in their free time. And Shahidi, having worked on the Pixar film “Luca“ and the upcoming “Elio,” manages to tell a story that feels familiar yet remains emotional.

    Related Review: Family Ties and Ruptures; ‘Le Coyote’ Turns a Compassionate Lens on Grieving Parents

    A scene from the short film Starling
    Happy birthday: A scene from “Starling.” (Photo: Tribeca Festival 2023).

    A Delicate Animation About Loss and the Emotions that Go with It

    I really find the storytelling both thoughtful and thought-provoking. Shahidi carefully constructs an otherwise-predictable narrative that weaves together various elements, capturing the complexity of grief and its impact on different aspects of life.

    And working with a team of fellow Pixarians and award-winning animators, Shahidi combines the tender storytelling and technical craftsmanship that further enhance the viewing experience. ‘Starling’s’ visuals and playful score evoke a range of emotions, culminating in a heartstring-tugging scene to the tune of ‘Happy Birthday’.

    “Starling’s” themes of grief and loss also invite another possible emotion in the long run — healing. Long after the credits roll, the short’s final act might stick in the audiences for a while.

    Starling has a rating of A- from The Movie Buff staff “Starling” will have its world premiere at this year’s Tribeca Film Festival. 

    Donate to The Movie Buff's Buy Me A Coffee page

    animation family grief Mitra Shahidi parenthood Short film Starling Tribeca
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleTribeca Festival 2023 Review: ‘Corvine’ is a Tender Animated Short About Pursuing One’s Passion and Identity
    Next Article THE SEINFELD PROJECT: SEASON 6
    Paul Emmanuel Enicola
    • Website
    • X (Twitter)

    Paul is a Tomatometer-approved film critic inspired by the biting sarcasm of Pauline Kael and levelheaded worldview of Roger Ebert. Nevertheless, his approach underscores a love for film criticism that got its jumpstart from reading Peter Travers and Richard Roeper’s accessible, reader-friendly reviews. As SEO Manager/Assistant Editor for the site, he also serves as a member of the International Federation of Film Critics (FIPRESCI) and the Society of Filipino Film Reviewers.

    Related Posts

    Independent June 15, 2025

    ‘Honeyjoon’ Tribeca Review: A Tender—If Tonally Uneven—Study on the Stubborn Bonds Between Mothers and Daughters

    Interview June 13, 2025

    Interview: Oscar Nominee Jessica Sanders On Her Upcoming Comedy Short, ‘I Want To Feel Fun’

    Independent June 12, 2025

    Tribeca Review: ‘A Tree Fell in the Woods’—But the Drama Barely Rustled

    World Cinema June 11, 2025

    ‘Cuerpo Celeste’ Tribeca Review: A Solar Eclipse Over Grief and Growing Up

    Movie Review June 10, 2025

    ‘The Day After’ Review: Epic TV Movie Demonstrates the 80s Don’t Hold Punches

    Movie Review June 9, 2025

    ‘High School U.S.A.’ Review: Old World Made for TV Comedy

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Latest Posts

    ‘Honeyjoon’ Tribeca Review: A Tender—If Tonally Uneven—Study on the Stubborn Bonds Between Mothers and Daughters

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 15, 20250

    Interview: Oscar Nominee Jessica Sanders On Her Upcoming Comedy Short, ‘I Want To Feel Fun’

    By Vidal DcostaJune 13, 20250

    Tribeca Review: ‘A Tree Fell in the Woods’—But the Drama Barely Rustled

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 12, 20250

    ‘Cuerpo Celeste’ Tribeca Review: A Solar Eclipse Over Grief and Growing Up

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 11, 20250
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    Indie Film Highlights

    ‘Honeyjoon’ Tribeca Review: A Tender—If Tonally Uneven—Study on the Stubborn Bonds Between Mothers and Daughters

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 15, 20250

    A curious trend emerged across several films at this year’s Tribeca Festival: characters retreating to…

    Interview: Oscar Nominee Jessica Sanders On Her Upcoming Comedy Short, ‘I Want To Feel Fun’

    By Vidal DcostaJune 13, 20250

    Tribeca Review: ‘A Tree Fell in the Woods’—But the Drama Barely Rustled

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 12, 20250

    Indie Psychological Thriller ‘Audrey’ Releases First Trailer

    By Mark ZiobroJune 10, 20250

    ‘On a String’ Tribeca Review: Isabel Hagen’s Viola-Playing Heroine Finds Humor in Stagnation

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 8, 20250
    Spotlight on Classic Film

    ‘Gone With the Wind’ Review: Epic Film from the Golden Age of Hollywood

    ‘The Count of Monte Cristo’ QCinema 2024 Review: A Thoughtful, If Rushed, Study of Revenge and Redemption

    ‘Thirteen Women’ Review: A Precursor of the Slasher Genre, with a Devilishly Divine Femme Fatale at its Helm

    “The Twilight Zone” Top 60 Episodes Ranked – Episodes 60-46

    The Movie Buff is a growing cinema and entertainment website devoted to covering Hollywood cinema and beyond. We cover all facets of film and television, from Netflix and Amazon Prime to theater releases and comfort favorites.

    The Movie Buff is also a leading supporter of indie film, featuring coverage of small, low-budget films and international cinema from Bollywood, Latin America, and beyond.

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
    Copyright @2011-2025 by The Movie Buff | Stock Photos provided by our partner Depositphotos

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.