“Guarding Stars” is the second Netflix Holiday film this season, and once again, they’ve raided the “Gilmore” vault. “A Dog’s Perfect Christmas” saw the return of Milo Ventimiglia, who played Rory Gilmore’s Season 2 love interest.
This time, we go back to Season 1, Episode 1 of the hit show, and the infallible Jared Padalecki. And if that’s not enough to tickle your nostalgia bone, Leighton Meester of “Gossip Girl” fame takes the lead.
“Guarding Stars” is based on a novel by Katherine Center. The screenplay was penned by a quartet; Erin Cardillo, Richard Keith, Gina Matthews, and Grant Scharbo. Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum directed.
Same, but Different
The plot gets credit for being unique.
Hannah Brooks (Leighton Meester) is a tough-as-nails bodyguard. She’s a former military person with a no-nonsense, no-time-for-fun attitude.

Jack Stapleton (Jared Padalecki) is a blockbuster action movie star. He graces billboards in Times Square with Terminator-type weapons, and the cover of People Magazine as the sexiest man alive.
A stalker has put Jack’s life in jeopardy, and Hannah, who is oblivious to his stardom, is assigned to protect him.
Meanwhile back at the ranch.
No, seriously, Jack and Hannah return to Jack’s hometown in Montana to celebrate Christmas at the family ranch. “All I can hear are my own thoughts.” The NYC Hannah scoffs when arriving in the picturesque Montana countryside. “No thanks.”
To avoid suspicion, they pose as a romantic couple for Jack’s family.
Andie MacDowell and Shaun Johnston portray the parents. Noah LaLonde plays Hank, Jack’s feisty younger brother. Siobhan Williams played Hank’s wife and got a laugh out loud moment when she’s introduced as Ella Mae. Tess Degenstein lends support as an attractive local cop.
Fun Cast
Skillset aside, it’s always fun to watch actors I grew up with playing as adults. Jared Padalecki is enjoyable as action star Jack Stapleton, who of course brings more to the story than meets the eye.
Leighton Meester was excellent in the 2023 holiday comedy, “EXmas” and once again demonstrates a potential arc for the next few decades of her career. She’s funny in a variety of areas with this part. Tough, serious, vulnerable. Meester can act circles around Padalecki, and they work quite well as a pair.

“I’m a bodyguard, not a human shield.” She explains while defending the one-foot-difference in height between the two.
Adding a veteran like Andie MacDowell lends credibility. The character is recovering from cancer and brings the emotional charge needed for any Christmas story.
NetfliXmas
We watch these movies as a temporary escape. I know it’s not going to land on my Top Films list, but I do know it will be fun.
I want a sequel. No, I want a sequel with Milo Ventimiglia sharing the screen. Better yet, a sequel that includes Lauren Graham and/or Alexis Bledel.
Netflix – make it happen!

