Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    The Movie Buff
    Subscribe
    • Home
    • About
      • Critics
      • Press & Testimonials
      • Friends of the Buff
      • Terms of Use
      • Thank You!
    • Film Reviews & Coverage
      • Movie Reviews
      • TV/Streaming Reviews
      • Film Festival Coverage
      • Interviews
    • Podcasts
    • Indie Film
      • Reviews & Articles
    • Advertise
    • Contact
      • Write for us
    The Movie Buff
    Action

    Review: ‘Knights of the Zodiac’ is an Unfortunate, Failed Attempt at Westernizing Manga Stories

    Erik Toth By Erik TothAugust 29, 2023No Comments2 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email Copy Link
    Knights of the Zodiac
    Mackenyu in "Knights of the Zodiac." (Photo: Toei Animation).
    Share
    Facebook Twitter Email Copy Link

    This year brought the live-action movie adaptation of the beloved anime franchise “Knights of the Zodiac,” or better, “Saint-Seiya.” The movie, directed by Tomasz Baginski, quickly proves to be yet another seemingly-failed attempt in recreating manga stories for a western audience.

    The badly fragmented plot of the “Knights of the Zodiac” presents Alman Kido (Sean Bean) taking in Seiya (Mackenyu). He does this in order to train him to find the way to use the mythical Pegasus armour to protect Kido’s daughter Sienna (Madison Iseman), who should be the reincarnation of the goddess Athena. This is all whilst the villain Guraad (Famke Janssen) leads a paramilitary group. She wishes to kill Sienna, to save the world from probable annihilation.

    Missing the Structure of the Manga Series

    The above plot is connected to the CGI series of 2019, but leaves out the structure from the famous manga. At a moment you’re left with the thought maybe the director and writers were not on the same page. At times it seems they wanted to produce a hybrid between “Power Rangers” and “Mortal Kombat.” Any of those is certain failure.

    The movie lacks structure and meaning, and the delivery is disappointing. The cast doesn’t excel, or even try to act as though they’re making an effort. The fragmentary approach towards to narrative proves the essential problem, felt after a few minutes: there was no real effort to create a solid frame to capture the true spirit of the manga story.

    No Brighter Days for Manga Adaptations

    It appears as though the destiny of live-action manga adaptations is still doomed and doesn’t look any brighter. Apart from some CGI scenery, “Knights of the Zodiac” is an amateur attempt at movie making. This adaptation only sheds light on the fact maybe sometimes it is better to wait, or maybe even to do nothing.

     

     

     

     

    “Knights of the Zodiac” is currently available to watch on Amazon Prime. 

    amime animation Famke Janssen Mackenyu manga Sean Bean Tomasz Baginski
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleCanon Construction & Destruction: Outside the Top 100, Howard Hawks’ ‘Rio Bravo’ Can’t Match the Energy of his Screwball Triumphs
    Next Article Review: ‘The Lighthouse’ Terrifying Mind Trip You’ll Either Love or Detest
    Erik Toth
    • X (Twitter)

    Erik is a movie enthusiast from Izola, Slovenia. He has been writing reviews for more than ten years for radio, newspapers, and journals. Erik admits that he loves Hawaiian pizza.

    Related Posts

    Independent June 15, 2025

    ‘Honeyjoon’ Tribeca Review: A Tender—If Tonally Uneven—Study on the Stubborn Bonds Between Mothers and Daughters

    Independent June 12, 2025

    Tribeca Review: ‘A Tree Fell in the Woods’—But the Drama Barely Rustled

    World Cinema June 11, 2025

    ‘Cuerpo Celeste’ Tribeca Review: A Solar Eclipse Over Grief and Growing Up

    TV Series June 11, 2025

    TV Review: How Seth Rogen’s ‘The Studio’ Marries Art and Commerce—and Why It Resonates as a Masterpiece

    Movie Review June 10, 2025

    ‘The Day After’ Review: Epic TV Movie Demonstrates the 80s Don’t Hold Punches

    Movie Review June 9, 2025

    ‘High School U.S.A.’ Review: Old World Made for TV Comedy

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Latest Posts

    ‘Honeyjoon’ Tribeca Review: A Tender—If Tonally Uneven—Study on the Stubborn Bonds Between Mothers and Daughters

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 15, 20250

    Interview: Oscar Nominee Jessica Sanders On Her Upcoming Comedy Short, ‘I Want To Feel Fun’

    By Vidal DcostaJune 13, 20250

    Tribeca Review: ‘A Tree Fell in the Woods’—But the Drama Barely Rustled

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 12, 20250

    ‘Cuerpo Celeste’ Tribeca Review: A Solar Eclipse Over Grief and Growing Up

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 11, 20250
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    Indie Film Highlights

    ‘Honeyjoon’ Tribeca Review: A Tender—If Tonally Uneven—Study on the Stubborn Bonds Between Mothers and Daughters

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 15, 20250

    A curious trend emerged across several films at this year’s Tribeca Festival: characters retreating to…

    Interview: Oscar Nominee Jessica Sanders On Her Upcoming Comedy Short, ‘I Want To Feel Fun’

    By Vidal DcostaJune 13, 20250

    Tribeca Review: ‘A Tree Fell in the Woods’—But the Drama Barely Rustled

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 12, 20250

    Indie Psychological Thriller ‘Audrey’ Releases First Trailer

    By Mark ZiobroJune 10, 20250

    ‘On a String’ Tribeca Review: Isabel Hagen’s Viola-Playing Heroine Finds Humor in Stagnation

    By Paul Emmanuel EnicolaJune 8, 20250
    Spotlight on Classic Film

    ‘Gone With the Wind’ Review: Epic Film from the Golden Age of Hollywood

    ‘The Count of Monte Cristo’ QCinema 2024 Review: A Thoughtful, If Rushed, Study of Revenge and Redemption

    ‘Thirteen Women’ Review: A Precursor of the Slasher Genre, with a Devilishly Divine Femme Fatale at its Helm

    “The Twilight Zone” Top 60 Episodes Ranked – Episodes 60-46

    The Movie Buff is a growing cinema and entertainment website devoted to covering Hollywood cinema and beyond. We cover all facets of film and television, from Netflix and Amazon Prime to theater releases and comfort favorites.

    The Movie Buff is also a leading supporter of indie film, featuring coverage of small, low-budget films and international cinema from Bollywood, Latin America, and beyond.

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
    Copyright @2011-2025 by The Movie Buff | Stock Photos provided by our partner Depositphotos

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.