‘Wicked’ Review: An Epic, Deeply Moving, Flawless Translation of the Stage Musical to Screen

Watching Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo’s powerhouse performances in “Wicked” (directed by Jon M. Chu from a screenplay by Winnie Holzman and Dana Fox) was akin to watching Muhammad Ali and Joe Frazier’s legendary boxing match of 1971. Granted, Grande and Erivo didn’t throw a single punch.

But like Ali and Frazier in that pivotal fight 50 years ago, you’re watching two people in their absolute prime giving it everything they’ve got, their talent and prowess creating a spectacle that transcends the norm. And when the dust settles, you simply feel awfully lucky that you were here to witness it.

The bulk of “Wicked” takes place at the magic college Shiz University, where Galinda and Elphaba (Grande and Erivo, respectively) attend classes. A friendship evolves throughout the film between the two, though Galinda’s jealousy of Elphaba’s magic lends a sinister edge to their relationship. At times you wonder if Galinda isn’t befriending Elphaba in preparation for doing something horrible to her. When dashing new student Fiyero (Jonathan Bailey) arrives at the school, romance is afoot. But does he love shallow Galinda or the more complex and moral Elphaba?

Yes, Galinda may be “The Good Witch” but Elphaba is truly the more virtuous of the two, always looking out for her paralyzed sister Nessarose (Marissa Rose) and standing up for the animals in the film.

The Film’s Themes and Visuals

The CGI in the film is impeccable, from the steampunk-style technology to the abundance of anthropomorphic creatures throughout. Dr. Dillamond (voiced by Peter Dinklage), a spectacle-wearing talking goat professor at the university, is an especially adorable character. Dinklage gives Dillamond an optimism and joy for teaching underscored by world-weariness; like a sweet, loving grandfather who keeps a happy face around the kids and grandkids but finds himself haunted by wars and other traumatic events in his past.

Speaking of wars and trauma: if you’re expecting this film to be a light and fluffy musical, the complex thematic layers “Wicked” tackles—especially in the second half—might surprise you. There are subtle (and not-so-subtle) themes of racism, animal rights, and the creeping insidiousness of fascism—all topics that were covered in L. Frank Baum’s Oz books. Baum was socially progressive in some ways, having been a staunch ally of the women’s suffrage movement and an animal lover. He also understood the dangers of fascism and how it always comes slowly and quietly, taking hold only when good people don’t stand against it.

The Two Stars: A Closer Look

There’s been a lot of malice thrown Grande’s way through the years. Even so, one can’t deny her colossal talent. Sure, Taylor Swift is the current queen of pop, routinely drawing crowds big enough to have their own ZIP code; but Grande’s not just a triple threat; she’s a quadruple threat (acting, singing, dancing, and impressions).

Anybody who’s seen Grande’s appearances on Saturday Night Live knows she’s a true chameleon, able to lose herself in any role she takes on. As Galinda Upland, she manages to be charming despite the fact that her character is bratty and narcissistic beyond belief. And in the film, she’s always accompanied by her gay friend Pfannee (Bowen Yang in a hilarious performance), who hangs on her every word and fashion choice like she’s Nostradamus.

On the other hand, Erivo’s Elphaba Thropp (who’s destined to become the Wicked Witch of the West) serves as Galinda’s antithesis. She has lived a hard life, her green skin condemning her to a life of a pariah and outcast. Her father even hates her but tolerates her.

Having to live a life of isolation and constant bullying, Elphaba developed misanthropy, rarely talking to anyone and burying herself in books. Erivo portrays her splendidly, giving Elphaba gravitas that makes the audience’s heart break for her throughout the film. Her magic is powerful, which, of course, makes her even more terrifying and strange to those around her.

A Love of Film History

Director Chu obviously has a great love of film history, giving so many great nods to the past throughout “Wicked.” There’s a Busby Berkeley-style musical sequence set in Shiz University’s library (which has so many revolving rooms and rotating shelves that it would give M.C. Escher nightmares) that’s reminiscent of the dance sequence from 1937’s “Ready, Willing and Able,” where Ruby Keeler and Lee Dixon danced atop a giant typewriter. Here, that sequence is magnified by 100, and to say that dazzles would be a massive understatement.

Later in the film, there’s a Bob Fosse-style dance number, the players contorting their bodies in that slithery geometry that Fosse loved so much. The scene feels like something out of Fosse’s film “Sweet Charity.”

There’s also a terrifying sequence where two of the characters are running down a hallway as hands come crashing through the walls and windows, which reminded me of that haunting scene in Jean Cocteau’s 1946 film “Beauty and the Beast.” In that film, the main character runs through a corridor as phantom hands grab at her from the walls at every angle.

‘Wicked’: An Epic Experience

The word “epic” gets tossed around a lot these days. Every big-budget film released in the last few years promises to be “an epic experience.”

“Wicked,” however, justifies that claim. Chu’s love of film is infectious. This musical (just the first part of what’s shaping up to be a glorious two-parter) has so many soaring musical numbers, plot twists, great characters, and touching moments that you walk out of the theater realizing that you’ve TRULY seen an epic film.

“Wicked” was theatrically released in the United States on November 22, 2024. The sequel, “Wicked Part Two,” is scheduled to be released on November 21, 2025. Follow us for more coverage.