Review: ‘Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story’ True Horror to Prep You for October

“Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story” is the latest serial killer flick to land on Netflix. They’ve successfully covered the likes of Ted Bundy, Richard Ramirez, and John Wayne Gacy among others. This ten-episode production doesn’t rely on archival footage and authentic interviews with real people. It’s scripted, directed, and produced like an actual motion picture.

“Monster” was created by filmmakers Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan. Both of which have had success with various horror shows and films. Different directors handle each of the episodes. It’s a stylistic production. The story is told in non-chronological format. There are dream sequences and some artistic liberties. But it’s done so well, you’ll think you are watching real events as they unfold.

The acting is amazing

Evan Peters stars as Jeffrey Dahmer. I know Peters from “American Horror Story” and a brief stint on “The Office.” Here, he is unrecognizable. Peters must have gone totally method for the role. He looks, acts, and sounds exactly like Dahmer. He has the voice ticks and the mannerisms down to an art. His performance will leave you terrified. You’ll hate Dahmer. At times, you will sympathies for him. Evan Peters gives the viewer a real look at the madness inside the monster.

The supporting cast is equally effective. Richard Jenkins plays Dahmer’s father Lionel. Again the performance will render you in awe. We can understand the burdens Dahmer’s crimes have on his own family. And in particular, his father who at times blames himself. Niecy Nash plays Glenda Cleveland, Dahmer’s neighbor. And I was shocked to discover that stepmother Shari was played by Molly Ringwald. Watching actual courtroom footage we can see how spot on the casting choices are.

Its a 10 episode series

What makes “Monster” different is the length of the production. While most of the serial killer docs run four episodes, this one goes with ten – each about an hour long. This allows for coverage of Dahmer’s life and crimes. That’s to be expected. But we also get a more in-depth look at the family members and victims. These facets are often forgotten about as we glorify the murderer, and it’s refreshing to see. The courtroom drama is covered as well, but never to the extreme.

Each of the ten episodes covers a specific time or event. We see his childhood and problems at home. How alcohol was a factor. Episode 6 titled “Silence” is unlike anything I have ever watched. I won’t spoil the details. But it shocked me when it came on and was one of the best parts of the series.

I will offer critique at the social elements. It’s well established that the Milwaukee police made plenty of mistakes in this case. There’s a bit too much anti-cop sentiment that I feel gets in the way at times. We know there are bad cops. There’s no need to embellish facts to further advance the narrative. Dahmer murdered seventeen people. He’s the bad guy.

We are one week away from 31 Days of Halloween. And this is real life horror at its worst. If you want saws, blood, torture, zombies, and a high body count, forget Jason Voorhees. Check out “Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story” for some real terror.

“Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story” is currently only available to stream on Netflix.

Support the Site: Consider becoming a sponsor to unlock exclusive, member-only content and help support The Movie Buff!